=====Background=====
Your honor, my name is Matthew100x, Partner Attorney at Inperium & Partner Law Firm. I am here today to bring forward a case on behalf of BlackSyth against Dwerpy.
My client and plaintiff, Blacksyth, requested that the defendant, Dwerpy, build his mansion at mansion12 in the mansion district of Capital City. He gave Dwerpy 35,000 krunas to accomplish this task (Screenshot_133.png and Agreement.png).
As of 1:06 AM EST, Dwerpy made a thread stating that he was going to leave the server (Dwerpy Goodbye.png).
My client privately asked Dwerpy to return the money that he gave him to build his mansion. Dwerpy responded that he could only give Blacksyth back 10k of the 35k he owed him (Blacksyth and Dwerpy.png). My client disagreed
This conversation went nowhere and left my client unsatisfied and uncompensated. He reached out to my firm to launch a lawsuit against Dwerpy (Blacksyth and Matthew100x.png).
After chatting with Blacksyth, he has told me he is only after 25,000 kr of the original 35,000 kr. Before launching this suit, I reached out to Dwerpy to try and settle this privately without bringing this to Court. My client Blacksyth is okay with 10k if he in addition is able to have Dwerpy's plot at Central Market Mall, CMM-23. Dwerpy rejected my offer to settle this privately out of court (Private Resolution).
I've also been tipped by an anonymous source that ReaperEduardo may be holding money for Dwerpy. If this is true, then it is possible to use that money to help repay my client.
=====Argument=====
By leaving the server, Dwerpy is not honoring the expressed written agreement between himself and my client. My client has the right to say that he does not want to do business anymore with someone who is quitting the server.
While not a contract. A written agreement was made between my client and Dwerpy through both Minecraft Chat and Discord (screenshot_133.png and Agreement.png). This is a binding agreement.
Since Dwerpy has revealed that he is quitting while work on the mansion remains incomplete, he has broken that written agreement. It is only fair then that compensation is made for my client so that he may be able to hire another person to build his mansion.
While the question of whether or not Dwerpy is truly leaving remains in question, I would say that the concern of him leaving is enough to violate this written agreement. It is possible that he may stay, it is possible that he may go, that risk is enough for my client to want his money back. Therefore, Dwerpy owes a debt to Blacksyth.
In Fhlown vs. Olefante (December 15th, 2018), it is established that money or material belongings can be used to pay off a debt. Since Dwerpy is leaving the server, Dwerpy broke the written agreement and therefore owes a debt to be paid to Blacksyth.
Since 10,000 Kr is not enough to cover the expenses, I request that the court collect CMM-23 from Dwerpy as material collateral to be given to my client to meet the debts that Dwerpy owes. My client only seeks 25,000 kr of the original 35,000 kr. Between the 10,000 kr and CMM-23, my client will be fully satisfied and all debts will be considered cleared.
I conclude my opening Argument.
Your honor, my name is Matthew100x, Partner Attorney at Inperium & Partner Law Firm. I am here today to bring forward a case on behalf of BlackSyth against Dwerpy.
My client and plaintiff, Blacksyth, requested that the defendant, Dwerpy, build his mansion at mansion12 in the mansion district of Capital City. He gave Dwerpy 35,000 krunas to accomplish this task (Screenshot_133.png and Agreement.png).
As of 1:06 AM EST, Dwerpy made a thread stating that he was going to leave the server (Dwerpy Goodbye.png).
My client privately asked Dwerpy to return the money that he gave him to build his mansion. Dwerpy responded that he could only give Blacksyth back 10k of the 35k he owed him (Blacksyth and Dwerpy.png). My client disagreed
This conversation went nowhere and left my client unsatisfied and uncompensated. He reached out to my firm to launch a lawsuit against Dwerpy (Blacksyth and Matthew100x.png).
After chatting with Blacksyth, he has told me he is only after 25,000 kr of the original 35,000 kr. Before launching this suit, I reached out to Dwerpy to try and settle this privately without bringing this to Court. My client Blacksyth is okay with 10k if he in addition is able to have Dwerpy's plot at Central Market Mall, CMM-23. Dwerpy rejected my offer to settle this privately out of court (Private Resolution).
I've also been tipped by an anonymous source that ReaperEduardo may be holding money for Dwerpy. If this is true, then it is possible to use that money to help repay my client.
=====Argument=====
By leaving the server, Dwerpy is not honoring the expressed written agreement between himself and my client. My client has the right to say that he does not want to do business anymore with someone who is quitting the server.
While not a contract. A written agreement was made between my client and Dwerpy through both Minecraft Chat and Discord (screenshot_133.png and Agreement.png). This is a binding agreement.
Since Dwerpy has revealed that he is quitting while work on the mansion remains incomplete, he has broken that written agreement. It is only fair then that compensation is made for my client so that he may be able to hire another person to build his mansion.
While the question of whether or not Dwerpy is truly leaving remains in question, I would say that the concern of him leaving is enough to violate this written agreement. It is possible that he may stay, it is possible that he may go, that risk is enough for my client to want his money back. Therefore, Dwerpy owes a debt to Blacksyth.
In Fhlown vs. Olefante (December 15th, 2018), it is established that money or material belongings can be used to pay off a debt. Since Dwerpy is leaving the server, Dwerpy broke the written agreement and therefore owes a debt to be paid to Blacksyth.
Since 10,000 Kr is not enough to cover the expenses, I request that the court collect CMM-23 from Dwerpy as material collateral to be given to my client to meet the debts that Dwerpy owes. My client only seeks 25,000 kr of the original 35,000 kr. Between the 10,000 kr and CMM-23, my client will be fully satisfied and all debts will be considered cleared.
I conclude my opening Argument.